The Best Italian Restaurants in Pinetop, AZ
Nestled in the heart of Arizona’s White Mountains, Pinetop-Lakeside is a charming destination known for its scenic beauty, outdoor adventures, and, increasingly, its vibrant culinary scene. Among the many dining options, Italian cuisine stands out as a crowd favorite, offering comfort, flavor, and a taste of tradition. Whether you’re a local or a visitor exploring restaurants in Lakeside, AZ, or seeking the best restaurants in Pinetop-Lakeside, this guide will take you through the top Italian eateries in the area. From classic pizzas to homemade pastas and delectable desserts, these establishments deliver authentic flavors that make dining in Pinetop, AZ, unforgettable. We’ll also spotlight Red Devil Restaurant & Bar photos and dive into why Red Devil Pinetop is a must-visit. Let’s embark on a culinary journey to discover the best Italian restaurants in Pinetop, AZ!
Why Italian Cuisine Shines in Pinetop-Lakeside
Italian food is universally loved for its rich flavors, comforting dishes, and versatility. In Pinetop-Lakeside, Italian restaurants cater to a wide range of tastes, offering everything from wood-fired pizzas to creamy risottos and decadent cannolis. The area’s relaxed, mountain-town vibe pairs perfectly with the warmth of Italian dining, making it an ideal spot for families, couples, and foodies alike. Whether you’re craving a hearty plate of lasagna or a fresh Caprese salad, the restaurants in Pinetop-Lakeside deliver quality and authenticity.
The Italian dining scene here is diverse, with eateries ranging from cozy, family-owned spots to more upscale venues. Many of these restaurants source fresh ingredients and incorporate local flair, ensuring a unique dining experience. Plus, with options for dine-in, takeout, and even delivery, you can enjoy Italian cuisine in the way that suits you best. Let’s explore the top Italian restaurants in Pinetop, AZ, with a special focus on Red Devil Pinetop and other local gems.
1. Red Devil Restaurant & Bar
When it comes to Italian dining in Pinetop, Red Devil Restaurant & Bar is a standout. Located at 1774 E White Mountain Blvd, Pinetop-Lakeside, this family-owned establishment has been serving up delicious Italian fare for over six decades. Known for its welcoming atmosphere and extensive menu, Red Devil Pinetop is a go-to for locals and tourists alike. Whether you’re searching for restaurants in Lakeside, AZ, or exploring restaurants in Pinetop-Lakeside, Red Devil is a name that consistently tops the list.
Why Red Devil Stands Out
Red Devil Restaurant & Bar is celebrated for its diverse menu, which combines traditional Italian recipes with modern twists. From their signature pizzas to hearty pasta dishes, every item is crafted with care. The restaurant’s commitment to quality is evident in its use of fresh ingredients and time-honored techniques passed down through four generations.
Must-Try Dishes:
- Red Devil Combo Pizza: Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and more, this pizza is a crowd-pleaser.
- Chicken Marsala: Tender chicken breasts in a tangy wine sauce with mushrooms, served over pasta, have earned rave reviews for their fork-tender texture.
- Tiramisu: A decadent dessert that’s described as “to die for” by patrons.
- Antipasto Salad: A fresh, flavorful starter packed with Italian meats, cheeses, and veggies.
Ambiance and Experience
The ambiance at Red Devil Pinetop is warm and inviting, making it perfect for family dinners, date nights, or casual outings with friends. The restaurant’s manager, Adam, is often praised for his hospitality, ensuring every guest feels welcome. For those curious about the vibe, Red Devil Restaurant & Bar photos showcase a cozy interior with rustic touches, complemented by a lively bar area where you can enjoy drinks like their popular raspberry margarita.
Why Visit?
If you’re looking for authentic Italian cuisine with a mountain-town charm, Red Devil Pinetop is a must. They also offer catering services for events, making it a versatile choice for special occasions. Check their website for coupons and specials to save on your next visit. For reservations or inquiries, call (928) 367-5570.
2. Italian Lady of Pinetop Cannoli Shack & Kitchen
For those with a penchant for sandwiches and sweets, Italian Lady of Pinetop Cannoli Shack & Kitchen at 1641 W White Mountain Blvd is a hidden gem among restaurants in Lakeside, AZ. This quaint spot specializes in Italian subs and cannolis, earning a stellar 4.6-star rating from 84 reviews. It’s a favorite for those seeking a quick, delicious meal with a personal touch.
What to Expect
The Italian Lady of Pinetop is known for its made-to-order sandwiches and desserts that pack a punch. The owner’s warmth and dedication shine through, with one reviewer recounting a four-hour drive just to try their sandwiches, saying, “The Italian lady is also the nicest person. Thank you again for waiting for us in the pouring rain.” The menu is concise but flavorful, focusing on quality over quantity.
Must-Try Dishes:
- Italian Sub: Packed with meats, cheeses, and a dressing that soaks perfectly into the bread, this sub is a fan favorite.
- Sicilian Cannoli: Made fresh to order, these cannolis are described as “huge and full of flavor.”
- Italian Lemon Cream Cake: A refreshing dessert that’s a perfect end to any meal.
- Meatball Sammie: Hearty and packed with homemade meatballs, this sandwich is a hit for meat lovers.
Ambiance and Accessibility
The Italian Lady of Pinetop offers a cozy, no-frills setting ideal for takeout or a quick bite. Parking can be tricky, but handicap spots are available, making it accessible for all. The focus here is on the food, with a small but welcoming space that reflects the owner’s passion for Italian cuisine.
Why Visit?
If you’re searching for restaurants in Pinetop-Lakeside that offer unique, homemade dishes, this cannoli shack is a must-visit. It’s perfect for a quick lunch or a sweet treat to enjoy while exploring the White Mountains. Call (928) 358-4928 to place an order or check their hours.
3. The Spaghetti Shack
For classic Italian comfort food, The Spaghetti Shack at 592 W White Mountain Blvd is a top pick among restaurants in Pinetop-Lakeside. With a 4.4-star rating from 62 reviews, this family-friendly spot is known for its hearty portions and crowd-pleasing dishes. It’s especially popular for those with picky eaters, as the menu is approachable yet delicious.
Highlights of The Spaghetti Shack
The Spaghetti Shack specializes in, you guessed it, spaghetti! Their sauces and meatballs are made in-house, earning praise for their rich flavors. One reviewer raved, “The sauce was amazing! The meatballs were phenomenal! And the service was super friendly and fast.” The restaurant also supports local causes, often hosting fundraisers, which adds to its community appeal.
Must-Try Dishes:
- Spaghetti and Meatball Special: A generous portion of spaghetti with flavorful meatballs and marinara sauce.
- Cheesy Bread: A side that’s perfect for sharing (or not!).
- Meatball Sub: Packed with their signature meatballs, this sub is a hearty option for lunch or dinner.
- Full Loaf Garlic Bread: Crispy, buttery, and perfect for soaking up extra sauce.
Ambiance and Service
The Spaghetti Shack offers a laid-back, family-oriented atmosphere, making it a great choice for groups. The service is fast and friendly, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. It’s a fantastic spot for those seeking restaurants in Lakeside, AZ that cater to all ages.
Why Visit?
If you’re after affordable, satisfying Italian fare, The Spaghetti Shack delivers. Its focus on classic dishes and community involvement makes it a beloved local spot. Check their menu online or call to confirm hours, as they’re known for their efficiency with takeout orders.
4. Paste House
Located at 2188 E White Mountain Blvd, Pasta House is another excellent choice for Italian dining in Pinetop-Lakeside. With a 4.1-star rating from 101 reviews, this restaurant is praised for its authentic dishes and calming atmosphere, making it a go-to for special occasions.
What Makes Pasta House Special?
Pasta House offers a menu filled with Italian classics, from lasagna to chicken Parmesan. Reviewers love the attentive staff and quiet ambiance, which sets it apart from busier spots. One patron noted, “The food is authentic and delicious! We try to dine there at least once a month and ALWAYS on special occasions!”
Must-Try Dishes:
- Eggplant Parmesan: A vegetarian favorite with perfectly breaded eggplant and rich marinara.
- Chicken Marsala: Another take on this classic dish, served with a side of spaghetti.
- Antipasto Salad: A fresh starter that complements any entrée.
- Lasagna with Meat: Hearty and packed with layers of flavor.
Ambiance and Dining Experience
The Pasta House offers a serene setting, ideal for those seeking a more intimate dining experience. The staff’s attentiveness and the restaurant’s cozy decor make it a great choice for date nights or family celebrations. It’s a standout among restaurants in Pinetop-Lakeside for its balance of quality and ambiance.
Why Visit?
For authentic Italian dishes in a relaxed setting, Pasta House is a top contender. Call (928) 367-2782 to reserve a table or inquire about their menu.
5. Johnnie D Pizzeria
Rounding out our list is Johnnie D Pizzeria at 1399 W White Mountain Blvd, a beloved spot for pizza and pasta lovers. With a 4.2-star rating from 61 reviews, this pizzeria is known for its authentic New York-style pizza and generous portions.
What to Love about Johnnie D’s
Johnnie D’s is a haven for pizza enthusiasts, with a crust that’s described as “perfect” by reviewers. The menu also includes hearty pasta dishes and calzones that are “as big as your head.” A reviewer from North Jersey, a self-proclaimed pizza snob, called it “the only authentically NY” pizza in the area.
Must-Try Dishes:
- Large Pepperoni Pizza: A classic done right, with a crispy yet chewy crust.
- Pepperoni Calzone: Massive and packed with flavor.
- Chicken Parmesan: A hearty entrée served with a side of pasta.
- Fried Zucchini: A crispy appetizer that’s perfect for sharing.
Ambiance and Service
Johnnie D’s offers a casual, welcoming vibe, making it a great spot for families or groups. The friendly staff and affordable lunch specials add to its appeal. It’s a top choice for those searching for restaurants in Lakeside, AZ with a focus on pizza.
Why Visit?
If you’re craving New York-style pizza or hearty Italian dishes, Johnnie D Pizzeria is a must. Call (928) 368-8899 for delivery options or to place an order.
Exploring More Italian Options in Pinetop-Lakeside
While the above restaurants are the top Italian picks, Pinetop-Lakeside offers a few other spots worth mentioning:
- Cafe Pinoli (1676 W White Mountain Blvd): This rustic Italian-American cafe offers a rotating dinner menu with fresh seafood, steaks, and pasta. It’s a great option for those seeking a unique dining experience.
- R&R Pizza Express (1477 W White Mountain Blvd): Known for its pizza and wings, this spot is perfect for a quick, casual meal.
Tips for Dining at Italian Restaurants in Pinetop-Lakeside
- Check for Specials: Many restaurants, like Red Devil Pinetop, offer coupons and specials on their websites. Keep an eye out to save on your meal.
- Make Reservations: Popular spots like Pasta House and Red Devil can get busy, especially during peak tourist seasons. Call ahead to secure a table.
- Try Takeout or Delivery: Most of these restaurants offer takeout, and some, like Johnnie D’s, provide delivery for added convenience.
- Explore Red Devil Restaurant & Bar Photos: Before visiting, check online for photos to get a sense of the ambiance and menu offerings.
- Pair with Local Activities: Combine your dining experience with Pinetop-Lakeside’s outdoor adventures, like hiking or skiing, for a perfect day out.
Why Pinetop-Lakeside is a Foodie Destination
Beyond its Italian restaurants, Pinet trip-Lakeside is home to a diverse culinary scene. From American diners like Darbi’s Cafe to German fare at Munich Haus, the area caters to all tastes. The combination of quality food, friendly service, and a picturesque setting makes restaurants in Pinetop-Lakeside a draw for food lovers. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, the Italian restaurants here offer a taste of comfort and tradition that’s hard to beat.
Pinetop-Lakeside, AZ, is a haven for Italian cuisine, with restaurants that blend authenticity with local charm. From the iconic Red Devil Pinetop to the cozy Italian Lady of Pinetop Cannoli Shack & Kitchen, each eatery offers something special. Whether you’re exploring restaurants in Lakeside, AZ, or seeking the best restaurants in Pinetop-Lakeside, these Italian spots deliver unforgettable flavors. Don’t forget to check out Red Devil Restaurant & Bar photos for a glimpse of their inviting atmosphere, and make a plan to visit these culinary gems on your next trip to the White Mountains. Buon appetito!